[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
If you want to write on the topics for the week:

Intersubjectivity, Shibusa, rapture of the deep, captcha the flag, the bystander effect, Overwatch

But are not currently a contestant - this is the place for you!

Just link your entries here!

This is also the place for constructive criticism of those pieces.

If you submit at least one entry *and* give constructive criticism on someone else's piece OR just give constructive criticism on *two* different pieces - you are eligible to send me a vote to give a contestant immunity this week!

With the amount of contestants dwindling, that's a lot of power in your hands! So I hope you take advantage of it by participating!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
It's another week and another Home Game thread, with a Killing Floor twist!

This is a place to post your entries to the latest topic "“The future outwits all our certitudes” if you are not a current contestant. Maybe you were eliminated or dropped. Perhaps you are only now finding Idol but just want to write.

This is the place to link your entry!

The Killing Floor twist means that we are encouraging constructive criticism for the entries - and anyone who either (1) posts two pieces of constructive criticism to this thread OR posts a Home Entry and one piece of constructive criticism will be eligible to send me an email (at clauderainsrm@gmail.com ) to give me their top 3 choices for immunity for the week.

Have fun!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
If you've already read the Topic post http://therealljidol.livejournal.com/811500.html, you know what to do here. :)

***

For those *not currently a contestant in the competition* who want to participate though, you can post anything you like. :) A previously written piece, or one based on the topic "Critical Hit"!

The deadline is the same as the topic Monday, Dec 8th at 8pm EST

Have fun!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
Welcome to the Home Game/Killing Floor.

This is the thread to post your entries if you are not a current contestant. That's the "Home Game" element.

The Killing Floor is where other people come in and often constructive criticism on your piece, to give you the feedback to help make it even better.

Hopefully, combining them will give folks more incentive to take part.

However, if that's not enough - there is one more twist. Anyone posting two (or more) pieces of constructive criticism in this thread (or one entry and a piece of constructive criticism for someone else) is eligible to CAST A VOTE TO DETERMINE WHO RECEIVES IMMUNITY IN THIS WEEK'S POLL.

Which, as you know, can be huge.

The topic this week is "Gauntlet". Although really Home Game entries can be anything you want folks to look at! :)

The deadline to be eligible to cast a vote is one hour before the poll closes. Just send me an email with your Top 4 choices.

In the meantime - get to writing, and commenting!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
Because of events, I'm not sure who actually noticed this last week. But with how close the poll has been lately, this could be something that is extremely useful in the coming weeks - so I will cut and paste what I said last week:

Yes, you read that correctly.

The Home Game and Killing Floor have merged - with a twist! :)

If you are NOT a current contestant, but want to write something and link it at Idol, this is the place to come. That's the Home Game element. It's a chance to still have your writing out there, as a part of this place. If you *are* a current contestant, but feel like writing something extra - this is also the place to come!

The Killing Floor is where people go to receive constructive advice on their pieces. So, if you post something here, people are expected to do more than just a "Good job", and instead actually give you something that you can use to make the entry even better.

Mixing them is a move, but I wanted to make a *big* move, so here it is:

IF YOU GIVE CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM TO TWO OR MORE PIECES IN THE HG/KF EACH WEEK, YOU WILL BE ELIGIBLE TO VOTE ON WHO WILL RECEIVE IMMUNITY IN THE COMPETITION.

That's right. It's not just submitting entries or giving feedback on entries - there's actually *influence over the game* on the line here. :)

***

So submit your Home Game entry here - for feedback! :)
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
Yes, you read that correctly.

The Home Game and Killing Floor have merged - with a twist! :)

If you are NOT a current contestant, but want to write something and link it at Idol, this is the place to come. That's the Home Game element. It's a chance to still have your writing out there, as a part of this place.

The Killing Floor is where people go to receive constructive advice on their pieces. So, if you post something here, people are expected to do more than just a "Good job", and instead actually give you something that you can use to make the entry even better.

Mixing them is a move, but I wanted to make a *big* move, so here it is:

IF YOU GIVE CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM TO TWO OR MORE PIECES IN THE HG/KF EACH WEEK, YOU WILL BE ELIGIBLE TO VOTE ON WHO WILL RECEIVE IMMUNITY IN THE COMPETITION.

That's right. It's not just submitting entries or giving feedback on entries - there's actually *influence over the game* on the line here. :)

***

Since it's "Open Topic" this week for the main competition, that pretty much covers anything you want it to cover! :)

This thread is for HG entries - and feedback to them - only. Everything else should go to the Green or Work Room.
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
If you've got writing you want to constructive criticism on - or you are someone who wants to GIVE some, this is the place!

Just post a link to your entries here!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
If you are interested in Constructive Criticism for a piece of writing (it doesn't have to be Idol related) go ahead and post it here!

Everyone else - take a look at what's posted and give your best concrit! :)

It's really that simple!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
I'm going to open it back up to everyone this week. BUT I will ask that if you HAVE gone before, to wait 24 hours and if there is still one of the 5 spots available, go ahead and take it.

If you haven't though - this is a great chance to come in and get some of that good ole constructive criticism that you have been craving!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
Our weekly journey into constructive criticism is back!

If there are still people interested in having their turn at submitting something, who haven't already done so, this is your chance!

The First 5 eligible submissions will be our "honored guests" this week! :)
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
If you are interested in having a piece of writing receive some constructive criticism from your peers - this is the place to post it!

The first 5 entries, from people who have not already had their turn - are eligible!

Have fun!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
If you want constructive criticism on a piece of writing, this is the place for you!

Post a link to it in the thread, and people can comment.

If you have submitted writing for this in in a previous week, you are not eligible. But for everyone else, it's open for the first 5 people to post a link!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
While we are waiting for the polls to close, I'm sure there are also some people finished with their reading and voting! Which means that it's the perfect time to get some attention over here! :)

If you have some of your writing that you want to hear constructive criticism on. just be one of the first 5 people to post a link in the comment thread!

(Note: If you have already had your work featured in a previous Killing Floor, you are not eligible)
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
Did you post an entry for a previous Killing Floor?

If you answered "yes", you are not eligible. If "no", then the first 5 people who want to post something to receive constructive criticism from their peers, may do so in this thread!
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
It's time to get back at it!

If you have a piece, and would like to get some feedback, this is the place to do it!

A maximum of 5 contestants can post a link to their piece here. It should be something previously written (as opposed to this week's Idol entry) that they want to rework, it doesn't have to be Idol related.

After that, people can offer their constructive criticism. With the qualifier that it needs to be *constructive*.

If you submitted your entry to a previous Killing Floor, you are NOT eligible to do so again. (until I say otherwise)
[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com
What the hell is this? It's a special place for people to submit their work for critique. Not "You rock", but no being an asshat either. Actually looking at the work and thinking of ways to make it better.

Why "The Killing Floor"? - I've had this in mind for awhile. The working name was "The Cutting Room Floor". But then I got that Howlin' Wolf song stuck in my head, and thought it sounded better. :)

How does it work? People submit their work - from a previous week of Idol or non-Idol work (NOT this week's entry) - here. I'm going to start out limiting to the first 5 to submit and tweek it as needed in the future. Then people come in and comment on it/make suggestions. Again, the purpose of this is to help. If you are incapable of giving actual constructive criticism (it's a shame that I have to say that, criticism should be constructive as a rule!) then this isn't the place for you, keep on going.

We're going to try this out and see how it goes.

Profile

therealljidol: (Default)
LJ Idol Presents: Idol Mini

January 2025

S M T W T F S
    1 234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 15th, 2025 07:48 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios