[identity profile] clauderainsrm.livejournal.com posting in [community profile] therealljidol
Wow, ok, when you people have opinions you have OPINIONS!!!*G*

So much to discuss here and I hope I don't miss anything.

I'm actually a little hestitant to address any of it, because so much of it comes down to "how so and so is playing the game" and that is just so very personalized. Honestly? If someone is playing a game that involves insulting other people (or making them feel insulted at the very least) it could just be who they are, but in the context of Idol, it's how they are playing the game. IMO it's not the smartest way to go, but it may be the most true to who they are, and thus I am extremely hestitant to point any fingers or step in by taking them aside and going "dude, you need to maybe take it down a notch." Who am I talking about? Quite a few people actually. Some of whom think that the people didn't see a filtered post, but people talk, and I think it's always a good bet, regardless of how private you think something is, to assume that if you put it out there, it's out there.

Pretty much all of the things I've read/heard/seen smoke signals about in posts, emails, phone calls and of course the above mentioned smoke signals are boiled down to playing the game.

Not from a personal level of course, but from a game perspective, which is ultimately, the only thing I can really talk about and/or do anything about.

If someone messes with you to the point that it rattles you - what has happened? They have managed to get ahead of one more person. Is this their ultimate intent? Who knows. I certainly don't. Maybe they just don't like you. Maybe you don't like them. People don't like everyone, and sometimes that person they don't like is you.

There are plenty of people *I* don't like. Heck, I'm on that list somedays!*g*

Not everyone has to get along to play against each other. In fact, one of the most interesting rounds was settled back in Season 1 by ONE VOTE from people who really couldn't stand each other's writing at all. That was pretty intense. But it did teach me a valuable lesson, which is good for someone like myself who wants everyone to be all happy and like each other - sometimes that just isn't going to be the case, and for the sake of the game, you sometimes just have to put that aside and just ignore them the best you can. "The game" - heck, I'm quite sure there are people most of you work with/go to school with/are related to that you can't stand. The same applies here really.

That personal aspect aside, let's get into the tribes.

Most people seem to understand this, but some don't - so let's take a look.

The new tribes are entirely based on 1 and half weeks of voting. It no longer matters who has what sized friends list, and yes, it no longer matters who thinks who is the better writer. Tribe 4 are NOT "the best writers in the competition". Tribe 1 are NOT "the worst writers in the competition". What they are, quite frankly is the people who got the most votes. In the perfect world, would the people with the "best writing" get the most votes. Sure, but I can GUARANTEE YOU that you and I do not agree on who the "best writers" are in this competition. If I had money, and was prone to gambling, I'd put some serious cash on that. Who's right? Well I am.*g*

Seriously though, it is such a very, very subjective matter. What it comes down to is vote for what you like, and don't vote for what you don't like.

Hopefully people will get what I mean when I use this example:

You read a book. It's the best damn book you have ever read. It's not on the best seller list, it's not by some household name. Maybe it's a first time writer or just kind of obscure. Do you sit around and complain that this great writer isn't getting the attention they deserve? Just sit there and shake your head at a world that is too "ignornant to get it". OR, do you tell your friends about this book? Do you get them a copy or lend out yours to spread the world? Do you get them to tell THEIR friends.

Every last person on the best seller list had something that the people not on there lacked, and it's sure not talent. They had someone who believed in them enough that they did some networking for them, to put them in the right place, and with the right people to succeed. They got them in the right bookstores and got the right people who make the decisions talking about them. Anyone who's ever played on that level knows that it's a networking game, and often times it comes down to a luck game. Who can put the right ball into the air at the right time so that it ends up on the right person's desk.

It comes down to two kinds of people, IMO, those who would complain about the unfairness of the world, and those who actually do something about it to the best of their ability. The world itself is pretty darn big and complex. As it applies to this game though, it's wonderfully simplistic.

If you like something. If you think Person A should go further than Person B, then get them the votes they need to do that.

It's not a complex mystery. Support the contestants you like. Don't support the ones that you don't.

You break down each and every issue and it really comes down to that. Someone ticks you off, the ultimate "pay back" is not voting for them if you think their entry doesn't actually deserve one. If you don't like the person but think "wow, the entry was really good/interesting/thought-provoking even if I didn't agree with it" then that's even better since it means you are thinking things through and not just reacting from an emotional basis. But really, emotions play into every aspect of life and every single game, including this one.

But in Idol, like life, you get what you put into it. If you bring the negative emotions into it, that's what you are going to get out of your game.
If you manage to stay focused though, and not let anyone rattle you, you have a good chance of making it further into this game than you originally imagined was possible.

Honestly, and I probably shouldn't actually say this one out loud, but I think most people are smart enough to have figured it out already, or they will - people in the lower tribes actually have a better shot because they have more of a chance to survive on sheer talent without the worry of being overwhelmed. It's fairly equal "talent wise" IMO but just on that one issue of surviving one more week...which is all that anyone can ulimately do, the "lower numbered tribes" gives people who might have the talent but not the numbers, a chance to build themselves up, and hone their skills of getting that attention they deserve. It's a second chance, and a way to avoid just being picked off in a numbers game in the "higher numbered tribes". Plus, and I designed it this one, the people with lower vote totals are TRIBE 1. Why? Because that means people see their names first, and get more of a chance to read their entries as they are scrolling down the poll. There's less of a chance of getting "lost in the shuffle" and more of a chance of getting the support they need.

Let's see, what else? I saw someone say that the best writer didn't always win the season and that's what they didn't like... I point to the above. If you don't want someone to win, don't vote for them. If enough people agree with you, then they won't. I'd argue vehemently that we've had 3 seasons and 3 of the most incredible writers, and people, that I can imagine won them. "Best" is always a subjective opinion. But I'm going to go with a frequently quoted line on most reality show fan sites, which is that the person who wins is the person who deserved to win. Why? Because they were able to win and the sheer act of coming up with a way to do that is remarkable in and of itself.

There was also apparently was a comment somewhere about my taking people's suggestions for how to make the game better. I do listen. If it's an idea that I think will work, I impliment it. Almost never the way the person gave it to me, but that's because what they might think "man, this is great" when placed in the context of the game, it just doesn't quite work. The balance here is very important and pretty much every single idea that has ever been proposed - thus far - hasn't had that "right balance" to me that drives things forward, keeps things fun, and most importantly keeps things as "non subjective" as I can make a concept literally riddled with the prospect of subjectivity. Most of the ideas I've gotten over the years aren't "bad", they just don't work for the contest. They might work very well for something else, but this isn't "something else", this is LJ Idol, and at the end of the day I think it's worth all of the headaches and bumps in the road, some that might seem to be mountains and valleys at the time but ulimately, like most challenges, find a way to smooth themselves out.


I think that covers pretty much everything. It's nothing I haven't said before, and it's nothing I won't say again. But if you know of something I missed (again, I didn't go into specifics, because if you don't know what I'm talking about it's a good thing, and of course "want to trade?"*g* but I think most of the things out there fall into one of those categories.) please let me know via email clauderainsrm@gmail.com or clauderains@rocketmail.com (I probably check gmail more these days) and I'll look into it and address it.
Page 1 of 11 << [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] >>

Date: 2007-12-09 04:28 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] spydielives.livejournal.com
Thank you.

[wishes she had an applause icon for the umpteenth time]

[For those in the know, when should I post the "tribute" ?]

**ETA: DAYUM - First comment too?? Must be a slow news day**
Edited Date: 2007-12-09 04:28 pm (UTC)

Date: 2007-12-09 04:35 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] marjory.livejournal.com
There seems always to be drama in these'ere parts sooner or later... I'm putting on my snooping trousers to see what I can find that is silly, darn silly or extremely silly.

Date: 2007-12-09 04:36 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] lttledvl.livejournal.com
I agree with everything you said, Gary. I tip my hat to you. As I told another ljidol contestant, I'm not here to become Ms. Popularity (personally I abhor such things) I came for the opinions. Both my own and that of other people.

There are a lot of creative writers here but for me it all comes down to one thing, the strength of their convinctions and their willingness to stand behind them. I don't care how an entry is written; it could a beautifully crafted poem or flowing prose, if it doesn't strike a cord in me, if it doesn't make me feel in some way, then it holds nothing for me than a series of pretty words.

Yes, in the end, LJIdol is one massive popularity contest. That can't be avoided. Hopefully people will come to view it not as a contest of 'who's better than who' but as a chance to better themselves and gain a more open-mind of the world around them. And that's why I'm here.

Date: 2007-12-09 04:46 pm (UTC)
hopefulnebula: Mandelbrot Set with text "You can change the world in a tiny way" (Default)
From: [personal profile] hopefulnebula
For what it's worth, I don't think anything can be completely fair, but changing it up every few weeks helps with that. I like your system. :)

Date: 2007-12-09 05:00 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] toonhead.livejournal.com
It's like I said before, I'm still amazed and quite pleased to still be in this after 5 weeks, I wasn't sure about that. I don't think what tribe you're in really matters much, at least it doesn't to me. I've always been a bit weird about my writing, but enough people told me that I was good that I decided to just put it out there and let y'all decide for yourselves wether I'm good or not. *G*
I'm in this because it's fun. This has actually helped me to write more and not just assume that what I think doesn't matter, or that my opinion on something doesn't count. Cause I know it does. So being in this has helped a lot.
From: [identity profile] spydielives.livejournal.com
I thought I hid quite well for a while last season.

*grinning*

Date: 2007-12-09 05:03 pm (UTC)
hopefulnebula: Mandelbrot Set with text "You can change the world in a tiny way" (Default)
From: [personal profile] hopefulnebula
Aw, so no two-person tribes, then? ;)

Date: 2007-12-09 05:08 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] puppetmaker40.livejournal.com
Well thought out and well written. It is a game and needs to be treated as such. I don't slag people. I learned early in my career in the theater that that sort of stuff tends to come back and bite you majorly on the tuckus. But if I don't say anything it doesn't mean I didn't like what I read either. Time is an illusion to keep everything from happening at once.

So when are you going to enter under a sockpuppet Gary? hee-hee-hee

Date: 2007-12-09 05:09 pm (UTC)
hopefulnebula: Mandelbrot Set with text "You can change the world in a tiny way" (Default)
From: [personal profile] hopefulnebula
Well, I meant sometime in the next few votes. It'd just be weird to go from 120 to 60. (Besides, aren't we still an odd number?)

Date: 2007-12-09 05:10 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rm.livejournal.com
The thing that I find annoying about the "popularity contest" aspersion, that I'm sort of forcing myself to ignore, is that no one thinks about why someone might be "popular" or have a large friendslist. Those of us who have been on LJ a long time may have lots of dormant accounts on our lists. Those in fandom may have lots of people with fannish journals that aren't voting from them. Or maybe we've been on LJ so long (I was an early adopter) that there is a critical mass of people we have for whatever reason. I'd like to think that's about my writing, but I also know it maybe a fluke or because I psoted some naked pics like five years ago.

Life is networking. And success is often about whether you can make people want and think they can achieve the same success as you more than you make people annoyed that they haven't yet. Finding that balance is next to impossible. I tend to be terrible at it and ungracious about it and feel I often don't get where I want or "deserve" (and there's a fallacy, no one deserves anything -- life isn't scored) to be.

I have known people in my life who just have a light people are drawn to. And I don't think of myself as one of those people, AT ALL, which may or may not be true (I don't know if those people I think of know this about themselves). And when one of my good friends, who is much much younger than me and a former writing partner landed a big book deal this year, I was litterally gnawing on myself with pretty ugly jealousy.

I am competative and insecure. I am confident in my abilities but not in my interactions with other people. And I know I take things too seriously. Most importantly, I'm as entitled to be that way as other people are to be annoyed by it and deal with me accordingly.

I think a lot of the current dramarama is about people not getting that people are a) entitled to their neuroses and b) entitled to their preferences. And neither of those facts make it necessary for anything to become a reenactment of high school.
Edited Date: 2007-12-09 05:16 pm (UTC)

Date: 2007-12-09 05:13 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] marjory.livejournal.com
Are you a teacher? ;p

I'm personally about as dramatic as an omelette (unadorned) at an Indian restaurant... But I do know what you mean!

Now I'm wondering who doesn't like *me* so I can prepare the voodoo doll!

Date: 2007-12-09 05:16 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] sircaliban.livejournal.com
I was once in a taco bell.. had this huge fathead like cardboard sign that talked. It was late. And these guys came in and started trying to steal the cardboard cutout. These guys were tripping on themselves trying to get the thing out the door. It was huge!

Me and a friend calmly walked outside while they were trying to stuff the thing in their car.. and got their license plate number. They took off. The manager came running out as they took off.

"go go go" they shouted.

We gave the license number to the manager.. and he went inside and called the police.

Not 5 minutes later, a police car showed up and said.. "we got them."

So I get that Taco Bells have drama.. Especially late night.

Date: 2007-12-09 05:22 pm (UTC)
fidget: (Snarl)
From: [personal profile] fidget
Deep down, I'm a nice person. I'll do anything for anybody. But when I'm angry with somebody, my ire never rests. Yes, I'm one of those types. A thing that gets me to that point is when I feel that I've been betrayed on some level, and that has happened to me more times than I'd like to recount.

I exude a type of malcontent. I am often cold, distant, and often come off as insultingly condescending to people whom I don't really know. Call it a defense mechanism, something to test the waters, or something like that. I don't like being taken advantage of, and I feel that if somebody can weather my aloofness at first, then they really want to be my friend.

Why I bring this up: There have been many LJ Idol entries which I have not liked. I'm obsessed with grammar, so if something isn't well-written, it makes me say "I don't care about the subject matter. This just plain sucks." And I could comment with that, but what would that accomplish? I've just attacked a total stranger and made them feel badly about themselves for no good reason. There's no point to it, as I'm not trying to gage a reaction. Nobody wins in that type of game. So, I choose not to comment at all.

For instance, this week I decided not to participate at all. Not only was I uncomfortable with the subject material, but I was having a horrible week. As in, awash in the throes of depression and despair and oh-I-hate-my-life and not wanting to live and all of that. It would have been so easy for me to blow off some steam by going around to all the contestants I didn't like, to all the entries with which I found a moral discrepancy, and said "Oh, hey, you're a terrible writer!" or "Hello, whorepants!" or, I don't know, something along those lines. Since I didn't trust myself to not come off as being somewhat abrasive (even when I truly wasn't trying to be), I simply withdrew from the temptation completely.

Of course, there's that whole issue that I never know how to comment to people's entries in the first place without fearing that I'm sounding completely stupid, anyway, but that's another issue entirely.

Despite my original misgivings that it's just a dumb popularity contest, I signed up for LJ Idol because I wanted to be challenged. I know I won't win, but at least I get the chance to see how well I can do with deadlines and assignments. I'm sure that's why most others are here, too. However, I cannot fathom why the hell somebody would want to cause drama. I mean...well, I can't think of any other way to put this than who cares! Is your life that shallow and devoid of meaning that you have to stir up shit on a silly LJ contest that has absolutely no bearing on reality whatsoever? Tribes were changed. Whoop-de-crap! The ice age isn't coming, the sun's not zooming in, meltdown's not expected, the wheat has not grown thin, and London is not drowning. Or, for those of you not familiar with Clash lyrics, the world isn't ending because of it. Grow up. Find a hobby. And, most importantly, shut the fuck up.

Maybe this comment is too lengthy and wholly out of line because I'm finally blowing off some of that aforementioned steam. That very well could be the case. But the point I'm trying to make (I think) is that not only is unnecessary drama entirely lame, but it only proves how boring of a person you are to perpetuate it. And I, for one, won't tolerate it. A writing forum is not the place for that kind of garbage. And if I catch you at it, prepare yourself for a verbal asskicking. Because I'm nice like that and doing it for your own good.

Date: 2007-12-09 05:25 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] twystedpixie.livejournal.com
That was, quite frankly, the most well-mannered, kindest "rant" in the world, Gary. :D Please, feel free to trade places with my boyfriend when he has his panties in a twist about something I've done. :D

Date: 2007-12-09 05:26 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] dedamona.livejournal.com
at this point, i'm just thrilled to still be in the game. i have only requested votes from my f-list once or twice. they're busy people and i made the decision that other than on close weeks, i would stand on my own laurels. i don't pimp myself out or my entry. i don't make a lot of noise. i'm one of those people that prefers to have people make their own choices without my influence in the matter. thus why i'm half amazed that i'm still around.

of course, the fact that, due to family issues, i had to take byes two weeks in a row....yeah, that one may be part of why i'm still around. i don't know.

i'm in this contest because i love to write. i don't do it for winning. i don't do it for votes. i do it because i just want to write and it's nice to be in broader forum where it can be shared with others. if i get past another round, great, but if i don't, that's ok too. for me, it's not about winning a contest. it's about expressing myself and having the pleasure of other people being interested enough to read. i don't care what tribe i'm in or why. i just want to write.

it's a writing contest. those who are all up in arms over a voting process aren't understanding what this whole contest is about. it's not about the size of your f-list or how much attention you get via commenting in the green room. it's about writing, pure and simple. for me, the whole issue is nothing more than the tempest in the tea pot.

Date: 2007-12-09 05:30 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] browneyedgirl65.livejournal.com
7O7!!!

Dude, you owe me a new keyboard now. And a fresh cup of coffee.

Thanks for the chuckle.

For those of you wondering, 7O7 is LOL having fallen backwards over the chair. I first saw this in FireDogLake, but I don't know its full pedigree.

Date: 2007-12-09 05:30 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] twystedpixie.livejournal.com
I actually read all of that.

While I don't have your intensity of invective to spew, I do agree it's sad that there are people who would take this heretofore friendly, encouraging competition and shite all over it. I do get that not everyone will like everyone else's writing. Hell, there have been a few entries I've read and have thought, "Enh...not so much". But there's a way to go about commenting on someone's entry, their writing, with leaving your negative thoughts about them as a person at the door. A little bit of tact goes a long way...maybe people just need a nudge to be reminded of this.
Page 1 of 11 << [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] >>

Profile

therealljidol: wheel of chaos (Default)
LJ Idol Presents: Idol Mini

June 2025

S M T W T F S
12 3456 7
8 910 11 12 13 14
151617 181920 21
22 23 24 252627 28
29 30     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 2nd, 2025 03:32 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios