i guess we'll have to agree to disagree on that one. because i see it as two really different things. if it was true for the island then everytthing we saw, the entire show would have been false, meaningless. Like Newhart waking up and having his entire series be a dream. But it resolving the sideways world, while not the best option, really doesn't affect my view of the show as a whole. It maes me feel like the entire sideways world was sortof unnecessary, except in that it makes desmond want to go into the light on the island. Or in that it shows what kind of lives the characters could have had if Jacob had not been involved with their lives.